4 Tried-And-True Methods to Reheat Your Pizza to Perfection

Fact-checked

Pizza is one of the most popular foods globally, enjoyed in different shapes and sizes, with various cheeses and toppings, hot or cold. Nothing trumps a hot pizza with deliciously melted cheese. But what do you do with the leftovers? Our guide presents all the ways you can reheat pizza and which process has proven to be the best.

How to Reheat Pizza - Image 1

How to Reheat Pizza in an Oven

Reheating pizza in the oven is one of the best methods to retain the taste of your pizza from the previous day. Heating the oven, however, for a single slice is impractical and costly. But if you have larger pieces of leftover pizza, consider turning the oven on to get the best possible results. Using your range can also warm up the kitchen—so this approach may be better for the winter months.

If you decide to reheat pizza in your oven, follow these easy steps.

  1. Preheat the oven to 180° Celsius;
  2. Place your leftover pizza either on a preheated sheet pan, aluminium foil, or a heated pizza stone;
  3. Bake for 10 minutes or until the cheese has melted.

Place your pizza on an unheated pan if you want a softer crust. And for a crispy crust, use a pizza stone—excellent for homemade pizza and reheating leftovers.

DID YOU KNOW? The first documentation of the word ‘pizza’ was in the Italian city of Gaeta in 997 AD—most likely not the same pizza as our beloved dish today. Today’s pizza evolved from flatbread meals sold in Naples in the 18th century.

How to Reheat Pizza in a Microwave

Microwaving is the quickest method for reheating pizza, but you need to do it properly so as not to end up with soggy chunks of pizza. Microwave pizza becomes soggy because the microwaves heat up water molecules inside the crust. But if you do decide to microwave your pizza, follow these easy steps.

  1. Put the pizza on a plate;
  2. Place a cup of water next to the plate in the microwave (which absorbs some of the microwaves);
  3. Turn the heat on high for 30 to 45 seconds;
  4. Check to see if the pizza is heated to your liking.

Reheating pizza in a microwave doesn’t produce the best results, but if you’re strapped for time, or it’s the only option you have, it’ll do.

DID YOU KNOW? The first commercial microwave was tested and introduced in a Boston restaurant in 1947. It was 1.7 metres tall, weighed 340 kg, and cost $5,000. But microwaves for home use came on the market in 1955.

How to Reheat Pizza in an Air Fryer

You can cook and reheat a variety of food in air fryers, and they’re excellent for reheating pizza leftovers by following these simple steps.

  1. Put the pizza in the air fryer;
  2. Set the temperature to 200° Celsius;
  3. Set the timer to about five minutes;
  4. Enjoy your hot pizza.

Reheating pizza in an air fryer is an excellent option since you don’t need to preheat the air fryer—it only takes a few minutes to heat. And any excess oil from the pizza is caught in the drip tray to prevent a greasy pizza. The only downside to this process is that you can reheat only one slice at a time, but given how quick the process is, this shouldn’t be too bothersome.

The temperature and timing needed to reheat a pizza depend on the different brands of fryers. You should carefully read the air fryer’s manual or set the timer according to your previous experience.

DID YOU KNOW? You can bake store-bought frozen pizza in an air fryer. These appliances are excellent for cooking frozen foods and have non-stick surfaces so that the excess pizza cheese won’t stick.

How to Heat up Pizza in a Skillet

As previously mentioned, you don’t want to turn on the oven only to reheat a slice or two of leftover pizza. Instead, use a skillet on your stove burner and follow these steps. (Both iron and stainless steel skillets will do.)

  1. Put a lightly oiled skillet on the stove with medium heat;
  2. Add the pizza slices and cook uncovered for a few minutes;
  3. Add several drops of water to the pan;
  4. Cover the skillet and turn down the heat to low;
  5. Cook covered for a few minutes until the cheese has melted and the toppings are hot.

This is the best way to heat up pizza if you want a slightly moist (but not soggy) pizza. The few drops of water to the pan turn to steam, which prevents the pizza from completely drying out. This skillet approach is excellent if you have just a couple of slices and want a quick and efficient method to turn cold pizza into a hot meal.

And if you don’t have a skillet, you can use a non-stick frying pan to reheat takeaway pizza.

DID YOU KNOW? Cleaning a skillet is straightforward—all you need is dish soap and hot water. On the other hand, cleaning a pizza stone is the opposite—soap and water are a big NO. So, consider the cleaning process before you decide on reheating your pizza.

The Best Way to Reheat Pizza

Now that you’re familiar with the methods for reheating pizza, you may wonder which is the best process. The oven is the undisputed winner of this ranking for the following reasons.

  • An oven provides even heat distribution.
  • The taste is similar to freshly baked pizza.
  • You can heat large pieces at once.
  • It produces a crispy crust and perfectly melted cheese.

If you decide against reheating pizza in an oven, using an air fryer or a skillet on the stovetop are good options, especially if you’re only heating up a slice or two. But of all the listed methods, using a microwave is the worst option—often leaving you with a soggy, chewy mess.

DID YOU KNOW? Pizza is one of the safest leftover foods. It will keep in the fridge for some four days. But keep in mind, if you leave it out at room temperature, it only stays fresh for about two hours.

Reheating Pizza Dos and Don’ts

Reheating your pizza requires some thought. So consider the following dos and don’ts.

✅ Do…

  • Follow instructions: Regardless of your chosen process, follow the instructions listed above.
  • Reheat oven/skillet: You don’t need to preheat a microwave or an air fryer, but ovens and skillets need to be.
  • Wait for melted cheese: Reheating pizza must melt the cheese. Make sure it has completely melted before you take it out.
  • Ensure it doesn’t burn: Make sure the starch in your crust doesn’t burn, as it can give your pizza a bitter taste.

❌ Don’t…

  • Additionally season: Don’t add any oil or other seasonings because it will make your pizza too greasy.
  • Reheat after four days: If you’ve kept pizza for more than four days, do not reheat it; it’s not safe to eat.

Conclusion

If you’re looking for the best way to warm up pizza, our guide has listed several good ways to reheat your leftover pizza. Whichever method you choose, follow our instructions, and soon you’ll have a deliciously hot, good reheated pizza.

FAQ

What is the best way to heat up leftover pizza?

Our research has shown that of all the provided methods, the best option for pizza reheating is the oven because the pizza is crispy, retains its original taste, and the cheese melts evenly, similar to a freshly baked pizza.

How do you reheat pizza without drying it out?

Place aluminium foil or a baking sheet in the oven to protect the pizza from drying out.

What is the best temperature to reheat pizza in the oven?

If you’re wondering how to reheat pizza and at what temperature, preheat the oven to at least 200° Celsius. Ensure the oven reaches this temperature before putting your pizza in and leave it in for at least five minutes.

ABOUT AUTHOR

I am a curiosity-driven creature searching for answers — and questions — in the digital realm. From marketing through online business creation to software tools — I am fascinated by everything that can make life easier. When not looking for meaning, yoga and good food keep me grounded.

Latest from Terry

Gas Pizza Oven UK California King vs King Mattress [Mattresses Compared] Best Trader Joe’s Snacks [A List of 24] How to Deactivate Your Facebook Account [5 Easy Steps]

Leave a Reply