Best Innerspring Mattress in 2021

[Reviews, Details & Tips]

You may think that the days of spring mattresses are long gone and that today all the mattresses on offer feature memory foam and liquid gel. Well, to our surprise, the innerspring mattress market is still pretty much alive and kicking.

If you are one of those people who feel stuck with your fancy memory foam mattress that just didn’t meet your expectations, we will provide you with a list of the 7 best innerspring mattress choices you can try. We will also tell you how we created this list, and what we paid attention to when choosing.

Show more

Top 7 Innerspring Mattress Choices in 2021

1. WinkBeds

The WinkBed from WinkBeds brings the innerspring mattresses back in style. Its combination of springs, coils, and memory foam makes it a great solution for almost all types of sleepers. It doesn’t matter what kind of bed base you have, the WinkBed adjusts to all of them. Its natural materials reduce odor and mildew forming. Pick your firmness level and enjoy your sleep. Full Review

  • 120-night trial period
  • Great for multiple types of sleepers
  • Variety of sizes and firmness levels
VISIT SITE

Show More

The WinkBed from WinkBeds brings the innerspring mattresses back in style. Its combination of springs, coils, and memory foam makes it a great solution for almost all types of sleepers. It doesn’t matter what kind of bed base you have, the WinkBed adjusts to all of them. Its natural materials reduce odor and mildew forming. Pick your firmness level and enjoy your sleep. Full Review

Price & Warranty

★★★★★ 5/5

Material Quality

★★★★★ 5/5

Ease of Maintenance

★★★★★ 5/5

Comfort Features

★★★★★ 5/5

2. Saatva Classic

Saatva’s Classic Mattress offers great comfort and durability at a reasonable price. It’s a great choice for sleepers looking for versatility and those who like to flip and turn a lot during sleep. Its combination of different technologies make it appeal to a great number of sleepers. Saatva’s experience in producing both mattresses and adjustable bases, also make this probably the best innerspring mattress for adjustable base beds. Full Review

  • Firm
  • Hypoallergenic
  • 2 sets of coils
VISIT SITE

Show More

Saatva’s Classic Mattress offers great comfort and durability at a reasonable price. It’s a great choice for sleepers looking for versatility and those who like to flip and turn a lot during sleep. Its combination of different technologies make it appeal to a great number of sleepers. Saatva’s experience in producing both mattresses and adjustable bases, also make this probably the best innerspring mattress for adjustable base beds. Full Review

Price & Warranty

★★★★☆ 4/5

Material Quality

★★★★★ 5/5

Ease of Maintenance

★★★★☆ 4/5

Comfort Features

★★★★☆ 4/5

3. Serta Kleinmon II

In so many words, Serta’s Kleinmon II is a great innerspring mattress for side sleepers at a very good price. The 120-day free trial and 10-year warranty just prove how certain Serta is in their flagship mattress’s quality. Full Review

  • Warranty
  • Affordable
  • Naturally breathable materials
VISIT SITE

Show More

In so many words, Serta’s Kleinmon II is a great innerspring mattress for side sleepers at a very good price. The 120-day free trial and 10-year warranty just prove how certain Serta is in their flagship mattress’s quality. Full Review

Price & Warranty

★★★★☆ 4/5

Material Quality

★★★★★ 5/5

Ease of Maintenance

★★★☆☆ 3/5

Comfort Features

★★★★★ 5/5

4. Avocado Green Mattress

All in all, with Avocado you get the best organic luxury innerspring mattress, made entirely of organic and hypoallergenic materials, helping you improve your sleep in a natural way. Its combination of different materials combined with a large number of coils means that this is one of the most well-built mattresses out there. Full Review

  • Organic materials
  • Great quality of production
  • Vegan option available
VISIT SITE

Show More

All in all, with Avocado you get the best organic luxury innerspring mattress, made entirely of organic and hypoallergenic materials, helping you improve your sleep in a natural way. Its combination of different materials combined with a large number of coils means that this is one of the most well-built mattresses out there. Full Review

Price & Warranty

★★★☆☆ 3/5

Material Quality

★★★★☆ 4/5

Ease of Maintenance

★★★★★ 5/5

Comfort Features

★★★★☆ 4/5

5. Purple Hybrid

We believe it’s safe to say that Purple is the right mattress for you if you are looking for something firm and durable, especially if you are a heavy sleeper. The Grid technology helps with the airing out, and that makes it great for hot sleepers as well. It may not be the definition of a budget mattress, but it is a great choice if you’re looking for quality you can trust. Full Review

  • Very firm
  • Great durability
  • Constantly improving design
VISIT SITE

Show More

We believe it’s safe to say that Purple is the right mattress for you if you are looking for something firm and durable, especially if you are a heavy sleeper. The Grid technology helps with the airing out, and that makes it great for hot sleepers as well. It may not be the definition of a budget mattress, but it is a great choice if you’re looking for quality you can trust. Full Review

Price & Warranty

★★★★★ 5/5

Material Quality

★★★★★ 5/5

Ease of Maintenance

★★★★☆ 4/5

Comfort Features

★★★★★ 5/5

6. Helix Midnight

Helix’s Midnight just has a little bit of something for everyone. Whether you like to sleep on your back or on your side, this versatile mattress has got you covered. Breathable materials help your mattress remain odorless and prevent the formation of mildew. Helix Midnight also has great edge support so you know you’re in for long-term stability and quality sleep. Full Review

  • Customizable
  • Suits many types of sleepers
  • More affordable than most others
VISIT SITE

Show More

Helix’s Midnight just has a little bit of something for everyone. Whether you like to sleep on your back or on your side, this versatile mattress has got you covered. Breathable materials help your mattress remain odorless and prevent the formation of mildew. Helix Midnight also has great edge support so you know you’re in for long-term stability and quality sleep. Full Review

Price & Warranty

★★★★★ 5/5

Material Quality

★★★☆☆ 3/5

Ease of Maintenance

★★★☆☆ 3/5

Comfort Features

★★★★☆ 4/5

7. Aviya

Aviya calls its product the best innerspring mattress online, and it just might be correct. Of all the online mattress stores we checked, Aviya has proven to have one of the best price/quality ratios. Their speedy delivery and the 10-year warranty just sweeten the deal for all firm mattress lovers out there. Full Review

  • Eco-friendly
  • Online purchase
  • Customizable firmness levels
VISIT SITE

Show More

Aviya calls its product the best innerspring mattress online, and it just might be correct. Of all the online mattress stores we checked, Aviya has proven to have one of the best price/quality ratios. Their speedy delivery and the 10-year warranty just sweeten the deal for all firm mattress lovers out there. Full Review

Price & Warranty

★★★★★ 5/5

Material Quality

★★★★★ 5/5

Ease of Maintenance

★★★★★ 5/5

Comfort Features

★★★★★ 5/5

How We Created This List – Our Methodology

While compiling this list and preparing the article, we considered many different criteria in order to make sure that we are giving you a realistic innerspring mattress comparison.

In this section of the article, we’ll briefly go through the criteria and explain the importance of each one. These may prove useful when you are picking out your perfect mattress:

  • Coil Gauge

Innerspring mattresses may differ according to the number of individual coils they have. But that is not all, coil gauge is also an important factor. To put it simply, this indicates the thickness of the coils used. Thicker coils mean firmer springs, which in turn makes the mattress firmer and less bouncy.

  • Coil Count

As we mentioned, this is a very important factor with innerspring mattresses. Any mattress should have a minimum of 300-400 coils, with no limits regarding the maximum. A higher number of coils can mean a longer life span for the mattress.

  • Comfort

A very important, but also a very individual criterion. Comfort has different meanings for different people. Here you need to listen to your body the most. Maybe you prefer a firmer mattress, maybe you’re a memory foam fan, it all depends on your personal preferences. If you are sharing a mattress with someone, make sure you both test it before purchase.

  • Durability

You want to get your money’s worth, right? Well, in that case, you wouldn’t want a mattress that is prone to deterioration, and that is going to sag in a few months. To get as durable a mattress as possible, always ask about the materials, coil count, and if it is the right choice for your weight/height.

  • Trial and Warranty

This is an important factor, not only because you can get your money back in case you don’t like the mattress, but also because it shows you how much the manufacturer trusts their product.

  • Pricing

We can’t stress this enough. Always take your budget into consideration. Don’t think that just because you don’t earn millions, you can’t afford yourself a nice, comfy mattress. Many top manufactures have very affordable options, and they also offer installment payments.

  • User Reviews

We suggest reading the reviews before buying any product, let alone a potentially life-changing thing such as a mattress. Reviews may help you on your way to deciding what the best innerspring mattress for you may be.

  • Free delivery
  • 120-night trial period
  • Great for multiple types of sleepers
  • Variety of sizes and firmness levels
  • Delivery takes up to 2 weeks
  • Might be a bit pricey compared to other options

WinkBeds prides itself on offering 100% locally sourced and handmade mattresses. They offer a wide variety of options, from spring to latex-hybrid mattresses. Here, we will focus on possibly the best rated innerspring mattress, their WinkBed.

The WinkBed is a hybrid mattress, combining the spring technology with the soft foam top layer. It comes in different sizes and firmness varieties, and its high quality of production granted it many awards in 2020, including Slumber Yard’s Best Mattress for Heavy People award. The WinkBed is a great option for side sleepers, people with back pain, and couples since it provides amazing weight distribution.

Due to its amazing edge support (only 2% sagging after years of use), the WinkBed is also amazingly easy to use. The manufacturer recommends rotation every two weeks for the first 3 months and from then on, every two months. This is also a flippable innerspring mattress, so that is another possibility of prolonging your mattress’ life cycle.

Since it is covered with naturally breathable eucalyptus material, it does not hold odors and airs out pretty easily.

The WinkBed comes in a variety of sizes and firmness options, and the prices vary accordingly. You can choose any size from Twin to King Size, with firmness options from 4.5 (Softer) to 8 (Firm Plus), and it will set you back anywhere between $1,049 to $1,999.

It needs to be said that there is a $300 money-back promotion for online purchases at the moment.

The WinkBed is possibly the most recommended innerspring mattress on this list. Most independent reviewers praise it for its versatility and the fact that it fits different kinds of sleepers. It also comes highly recommended by reviewers from several news outlets, such as The New York Times.

Warranty Lifetime warranty
Night Trial 120-night trial
Shipping Free within the U.S.
Saatva Classic
Saatva Classic

The Most Versatile

Visit Website
  • Great for hot sleepers
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Firm
  • 2 sets of coils
  • May be too bouncy
  • Not good for those who prefer a soft bed

Saatva has been around for quite some time, building a good reputation for themselves. Best known for their quality and value, Saatva has built a big following, and people often recommend their products which range from beds to mattresses. Their representative on our innerspring mattress comparison list is the Saatva Classic Mattress.

The Classic combines foam with a layer of steel coils. This provides both comfort and durability, which makes it a great option for people who like to switch between positions during sleep.

There is another layer of memory foam at the bottom, as well as a set of smaller springs which improve breathability and make it more durable. The cover is made from 100% organic cotton, meaning that this is a hypoallergenic mattress as well.

Given the fact that this coil spring mattress doesn’t come with a removable cover, the cleaning is made a bit more difficult. Luckily, the foam materials do not trap bad smells and are easily aired out.

The Saatva Classic Mattress comes in a variety of sizes, ranging from Twin to Cal King, and the prices range accordingly: from $799 for Twin Size, up to $1,799 for Cal King.

This mattress also comes in 3 levels of firmness (Luxury Firm, Plush, and Firm), but these do not affect the price.
Saatva’ in producing both mattresses and adjustable bases and offers discounts on their adjustable bases with online purchases of their mattresses.

However, if for some reason you aren’t into their bases, there are many companies producing adjustable beds with great quality on the market.

Most users praise Saatva for their price-value ratio, and some even called it the best value innerspring mattress. However, it was also obvious from the reviews that this mattress was designed with firm mattress lovers in mind. So if you prefer softer mattresses or memory foam, you may want to look further.

Warranty 15-year warranty
Night Trial 180-night trial
Shipping Free white glove shipping and delivery
Serta Kleinmon II
Serta Kleinmon II

Most Experienced Manufacturer

Visit Website
  • Naturally breathable materials
  • Warranty
  • Affordable
  • Not good for back or stomach sleepers
  • Possible body indentations

Proudly naming themselves the No. 1 mattress manufacturer in the U.S., Serta has been around for almost a century. Their longevity and experience makes them one of the pioneers in the industry and certainly one of the most recognizable innerspring mattress brands. They made their name known by introducing the famous The Perfect Sleeper series, featuring our pick: Kleinmon II.

Kleinmon boasts a variety of materials and is a combination of individually wrapped coils and CoolTwist Gel memory foam, all that with enhanced edge support and wrapped in cooling, breathable materials.

The manufacturer suggests regular rotation and occasional flipping in order to prolong the mattress’s lifespan. As for cleaning, they recommend spot removal by using sodium bicarbonate or other mild cleaning agents directly on stains.

Depending on the size (from Twin to California King), this mattress can cost anywhere between $647 and $957, which puts it in the more affordable innerspring mattress group.

At the time of writing, there is an additional 10% discount on Macy’s website, with the promo code FRIEND.

Generally speaking, the user reviews are very kind to this mattress, except for a few negative ones. The negative comments were mostly related to durability and sagging, but in all honesty, Kleinmon II is not exactly the best spring mattress for back or stomach sleepers.

Warranty 10-year limited warranty
Night Trial 120-day trial period
Shipping 5-14 days within the U.S. (excl. Alaska and Hawaii)
  • Vegan option available
  • Great quality of production
  • Organic materials
  • A bit too pricey
  • Innersprings may cause excessive squeaking at times

Next up on our list is the best innerspring mattress for all environmentally conscious sleepers. Avocado prides itself on producing environmentally friendly, vegan mattresses, free of wool, or any other animal materials if that is the customer’s choice. Their No. 1 product is an organic mattress, very adequately called Green Mattress.

Avocado’s Green Mattress is an innerspring mattress made entirely of organic materials, such as wool, organic latex, and cotton. All that is supported by 1414 pocketed coils. Avocado offers a cruelty-free version of this mattress as well, called the Avocado Vegan Mattress.

The manufacturers clearly state that this is not a flippable mattress, but that occasional rotation is very desirable. Natural materials ensure that your mattress doesn’t emit any unpleasant odors and gas. In the case of cleaning, mild organic products are recommended.

Depending on the size, Avocado’s Green Mattress will cost you anywhere from $899 to $1,799. For an additional $300-$600, you can also get a mattress topper.

These prices don’t exactly put Avocado in the cheap range, but it definitely is the best quality innerspring mattress for anyone looking for organic and healthy alternatives.

We should also mention that Avocado offers a one-year free trial, with a 25-year guarantee and free shipping within the U.S.

The Avocado users absolutely love their mattresses from what we could find. They mostly praise it for its use of organic material, but also the very high quality of production and firmness which makes it an excellent choice for heavy sleepers and side sleepers alike.

Warranty 25-year warranty
Night Trial 1-year trial
Shipping Free within the U.S.
Purple Hybrid
Purple Hybrid

Most Innovative Technology

Visit Website
  • Great Grid technology
  • Constantly improving design
  • Very firm
  • Great durability
  • Too firm for some sleepers
  • Expensive

Purple is an innovator in the mattress industry. Their Grid technology has been continuously improved for many years and has proven to be longer-lasting and more durable than memory foam and its alternatives. The Grid allows constant airflow, preventing the formation of odors and mildew, and increasing firmness and durability. Their best innerspring mattress? The Purple Hybrid.

Purple Hybrid consists of several layers of different materials, including the soft stretchmax cover, their famous Purple Grid, transition foam, and of course a support layer of responsive, individually wrapped coils. This is an incredibly durable and firm mattress, and the Purple Grid technology also makes it a cooling innerspring mattress. This is why it’s a great choice for hot sleepers and anyone who wants some extra firmness in their mattress.

For cleaning, the manufacturer suggests using a mild detergent, such as an upholstery cleaner, while dry cleaning and machine washing are not recommended.

The prices of the Purple Hybrid vary according to the size and thickness of the Grid you choose. The Twin version with a 3” Grid costs $1,799, which is the most affordable option.

The most lavish option of this durable innerspring mattress would be a Split King Size with a 4” Grid, which sets you back $4,798. Purple also offers payments on a monthly installment basis.

The reviews for the Purple Mattress in general are a bit polarized. People who like firm mattresses are thrilled with this product, while others complain about the very same issue.

I guess it all depends on what innerspring mattress types you prefer, and this one is definitely not the one for you if you’re looking for a plush feel and softness.

Warranty 1-year warranty
Night Trial 100-night trial
Shipping Free within the U.S.
Helix Midnight
Helix Midnight

The Most Customizable

Visit Website
  • Heavy and stomach sleepers might prefer other brands
  • Breathable materials
  • Customizable
  • Suits many types of sleepers
  • More affordable than most others
  • Not good for sleepers who like firm surfaces

“The most awarded mattress brand in 2020” is how Helix advertise themselves. And indeed, their mattresses have won numerous titles, such as Forbes’ “Best mattress for side sleepers”, or The Best List’s “Best overall mattress”, to name a few. And spearheading all this is their top model called Helix Midnight. So let’s see what this mattress with great edge support has to offer.

Helix Midnight is another hybrid mattress, combining innerspring technology with layers of different types of foam (including a top comfort layer) with individually wrapped coils. They come in different levels of firmness, but Helix’s website offers you an innerspring mattress guide, so you can test yourself and decide which mattress fits your needs the best. On top of that, if you cannot find the right combination for you, Helix offers you the option to customize your mattress. How cool is that?

Since the layers on this mattress are strategically positioned, it is recommended not to flip it, but rotating is highly encouraged. As far as cleaning goes, like with most brands, mild detergents are recommended in case of stains.

Helix Midnight’s pricing varies depending on the size. The sizes available range from Twin to California King, and they would cost anywhere from $500 up to $1,199. This would put it in a mid-tier range, as far as affordability goes.

Many highly esteemed enterprises in the mattress business, such as Sleepopolis, have sung this mattress praises, calling it the best innerspring mattress for back pain, for example. But what about the end-users? Well, it seems that they share this viewpoint. Most users are very satisfied, saying that the mattresses are neither too firm nor too soft, which is a winning combination for most types of sleepers.

Warranty 1-year warranty
Night Trial 100-nights free trial
Shipping Free within the U.S. (with contactless delivery option)
Aviya
Aviya

The Best Innerspring Mattress Online

Visit Website
  • Online purchase
  • Customizable firmness levels
  • Eco-friendly
  • Too firm for some sleepers
  • Needs some time to break in

Aviya started out as a company looking to provide eco-friendly and affordable mattresses online; and that’s just what they are still doing. They are a go-to for anyone looking to get the best innerspring mattress with an ecological consciousness.

Aviya holds a CertiPUR-US Certificate, which guarantees that their mattresses are 100% eco-friendly.

The Aviya Mattress is completely free of any toxic materials, and it contains all-organic stuff such as pure cotton, flax, linseed, and even sea salt. This makes it completely hypoallergenic and breathable.

As far as structure is concerned, this mattress combines layers of foam and innersprings, which improves the airflow and keeps you nice and cool at night.

Due to it’s organic and eco-friendly build, the manufacturer recommends avoiding machine washing and dry cleaning. Occasional airing out and using mild detergents should do the trick.

Depending on the size (Twin to Cal King), the Aviya Mattress will set you back anywhere between $799 and $1,499. You can also choose your firmness level, but that does not affect the price.

Most users appreciate the versatility of this mattress, which is due to the combination of many different materials and technologies. The natural materials slow deterioration while also improving pressure distribution. However, it did receive some negative feedback, most of it because it was “too firm” for some sleepers.

Warranty 10-years warranty
Night Trial 100-night trial
Shipping Free shipping within the U.S. (3-7 days)

How to Choose an Innerspring Mattress

In this section, we’ll provide you with an overview of the most important features to look at when choosing an innerspring mattress. Here are some points to consider:

  • Firmness level

As you may have noticed, not all sleepers prefer a very firm mattress to sleep on, or a very plush, soft one for that matter. Before deciding if you want your innerspring mattress extra firm or cloudy soft, try to imagine yourself sleeping on it. If possible, go to the store and try it out.

  • Padding

The top layer of your mattress can be more important than you think. Always pay attention to how soft/firm it is, and also make sure that it is made from hypoallergenic materials, to avoid those morning nose clogs and sniffles.

  • Sagging issues

It is inevitable that your mattress will sag sooner or later. But you’d want to delay that as much as possible. To postpone sagging and prolong your mattress’s lifespan, first of all, make sure that you buy a mattress made from top quality materials, and afterwards make sure to rotate it and/or flip it regularly.

  • Mattress topper

Always a good thing to consider, if you have a budget for it. Mattress toppers not only provide extra comfort and support, they also prolong the life of your mattress. Sometimes a good mattress topper can add years to the mattress itself.

  • Budget

As we already mentioned, always keep your budget in mind but try to set aside a generous sum. Buying a mattress is a capital investment since the quality of sleep can affect so many aspects of our daily lives. Always research a bit more. You would be surprised at some of the amazing offers out there.

Innerspring Mattress Coil Types

We’ve already mentioned that mattresses may differ in coil count and coil gauge. But there are also different types of coils, springs, and spring systems and this may be a very influential factor in your choice of mattress. Here we are going to briefly describe the most widely used types of coils.

  • Pocket coil system

A system of individually pocketed coils – each coil is wrapped in a layer of fabric. This improves support while minimizing movement when the sleeper changes positions.

  • Continuous coil system

Instead of being individually separated, coils in this system are actually derived from a single wire. A mattress with these coils has a better structure and higher durability than a traditional innerspring mattress.

  • Offset coils

Unlike most coils, offset coils are hourglass-shaped coils with flattened tops. This unique design improves the mattress’s adjustability to the sleeper’s body.

  • Bonnel coils

The most traditional types of mattress coils. These are the ones you have in mind when thinking about innerspring mattresses.

Benefits of Innerspring Mattresses

In this section, we will try to briefly highlight some main innerspring mattress benefits, compared to other types of mattresses.

These mattresses are a great choice for people who prefer firmer sleeping surfaces and want to isolate motion transfer during sleep.

On top of that, innerspring mattresses (especially hybrid mattresses) are more breathable and provide cooling during sleep, which is amazing if you are a hot sleeper.

These types of mattresses have also proven to be more long-lasting, especially if they are regularly rotated or flipped. The springs and the modern materials used make them much more durable than most foam mattresses.

Best Innerspring Mattresses at a Glance

Key Takeouts

So, at the end of the day, we could say that innerspring mattresses are making a big comeback. They make good use of new trends and technologies, seem to offer more durability, and are firmer and apparently more long-lasting than most other types of mattresses.
We hope that our list featuring the best innerspring mattress options in 2021 will have given you some insightful and useful information to help you choose the best innerspring mattress for you.

FAQ

Are innerspring mattresses good?

Well, to put it simply, they are. But the real answer is more complicated. While innerspring mattresses have greatly improved in terms of quality and the variety of materials used, they may not be the right fit for everyone. For example, some users complain that they are too firm, and they might be better off with a memory foam mattress.

What is an innerspring mattress?

These mattresses, as their name suggests, contain a certain number of springs within their structure. These springs are what gives the mattress its shape, and they also provide support and promote airflow.

Of course, springs are not the only component of these mattresses, as they incorporate many different technologies such as memory foam, organic materials, etc.

Are innerspring mattresses good for back pain?

As with all issues related to health, and especially pain, it all differs from person to person. You may find many discussions online where different types of mattresses are compared. For example, you may wonder if the innerspring is better than the many-layered hybrid option, which apart from the coils may include memory foam, gel and other layers as well. At the end of the day, it all depends on the personal traits of the sleeper: height, weight, sleeping position, etc. Remember most companies offer a long trial period to help you find the best option. If you feel that innerspring would give your body a better level of support, make sure that you choose the best innerspring mattress from the numerous high-quality options out there.